Debate Rages over Gore’s Movie – Science is OK

You would think I’ve had enough of this global warming debate that is raging right now, but I just can’t get enough. On Tuesday the AP put out a story entitled “Scientists OK Gore’s Movie for Accuracy” that describes the results of a poll they took of over a hundred climate scientist including skeptics. Only 19 scientists polled actually saw the movie, but those gave it good marks.

Then today we see the Senate Committee on Environment & Public works issuing a press release entitled “AP Incorrectly Claims Scientists Praise Gore’s Movie” in which they blast the AP and go on to quote the usual skeptics who are on the payroll of large corporations trying to cast doubt on the science behind global warming.

This is getting out of hand. Why is the Senate wasting my tax dollars doing movie reviews? It’s important to note that is was a majority (republicans) press release by the committee – the minority (democrats) were busy introducing green building legislation while this was going on. I’m beginning to think this back and forth ping pong match has little to do with Global Warming and everything to do with politics.

Although with Exxon-Mobile footing the bill to the tune of $8 Million and other big-oil companies chipping in – I guess it’s possible to buy off a senator or two. James Inhofe is the majority leader of the committee that issued the press release, and it’s no surprise that the Oil and Gas industry is his top contributor.

It’s crazy to see them still bringing up this “hockey stick” argument again because this has long been laid to rest scientifically. (not necessarily politically) Even a National Academies Synthesis Report reafirms that the current warming trend is caused by human activity. The Real Climate web site summarizes it nicely.

“Despite the attempts of some commentators to attempt conflate the evidence for the existence of human influences on climate with the validity of a single reconstruction (e.g. that of Mann et al) it is quite clear that the evidence for anthropogenic impacts on climate is quite strong irrespective of whether or not the original “hockey stick” is correct.”

Even so, Inhofe has tried to co-opt this report and twist it to his own means and ends. But you can separate the Myth from Fact on the Real Climate web site. Inhofe is really starting to irk me.

6 thoughts on “Debate Rages over Gore’s Movie – Science is OK”

  1. You cannot change the minds of the people who believe global warming to be a liberal plot. I keep trying and I am unfailingly polite, but it does not do much good.

    I always send people to the website of the Union of Concerned Scientists:
    http://www.ucsusa.org/ucs/about/

    UCS was founded in 1969 by faculty members and students at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology who were concerned about the misuse of science and technology in society. Their statement called for the redirection of scientific research to pressing environmental and social problems.

    They may call me an idiot, but it is hard to say that about winners of the Nobel Peace Prize and top scientists in their field.

    Nice blog.

  2. I keep trying and I am unfailingly polite, but it does not do much good.

    You are right, logic is not going to work with most of them. It’s so hard to continue being polite to those morons and I have come to the conclusion that there is much more fun to be had by insulting their intelligence.

  3. Pingback: Hurricane!

  4. Hi there Dear, What you ?just written here really have me wicked up to the last sentence, and I must tell you I rarely read the full length post of blogs because I usually got bored and tired of the BS that is presented on the internet on a daily basis and I simply end up checking out the headlines and maybe the first lines or something like that. But your headline and the first paragraphs were outstanding and it right on the spot tuned me on your stíle. So, I just wanna say: nice and rare job! Thanks, really.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.